It's a good place to relax and get a hot coffee. Some dishes are just a little untasteful. The French fries oil tastes weird. Everything else is good
phenomenal bagels and breakfast sandwiches! this is my go-to BEC spot - they make the bacon so crispy and crunchy. truly some of the most perfectly cooked bacon.
I really like Catskill Bagel Co. I’ve been having bagels and coffee all week and it’s a welcomed addition to my local excursions. I also like the price - two bagels, tofu cream cheese (which you should try if you haven’t already), and coffee. $12. 🥯 ☕️
VERY good bagels. We had bacon egg and cheeses which I forgot to take pictures of because we devoured them. Pumpernickel bagel and everything bagel were spot on. My friend had the Cortelyou Road wrap which was also delicious. Hazelnut iced coffee was tasty. It was fast and efficient inside to order and everything was socially distanced and compliant with COVID guidelines.
Four stars because the bagels are really good and I never want to rate a small business low, but y'all need to figure out what's going on with your staff. When they get my order right it's great, but these days they get it wrong about 1 out of 5 times, even when I'm there during a slow time. I was just the only one in the store and they managed to get a garlic bagel with cream cheese wrong, how?
Edit: Once again walked out of here with a bagel that is untoasted (a sin) for no apparent reason. Get it together guys! I want to love you!
Went today with two friends and two of us had potatoes and eggs and my other friend had turkey and cheese on roll
Everything was so delicious and the vanilla coffee is good too
The owner was very gracious and nice. We will definitely go back very soon
UGH???!!!! ........So.....I paid 10 dollars for and extremely small salad that was not really appetizing. The first time that I ordered here the bagel I ordered was extremely delicious. Not sure what happened here smh maybe it maybe just my taste buds but in my opinion their bagels are better.
Ordered an everything bagel toasted with butter. The bagel was seasoned well and toasted beautifully. It was crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. I love the bagels at Catskills.
Today, I ordered roast beef on a bagel with honey mustard nothing else. The server asked me several times what else I wanted on the bagel and I said nothing just roast beef, no cheese, no tomatoes, just roast beef on a bagel. I got he bagel with roast beef, lettuce, sprouts, cheese and tomato. The owner came over and said the staff person was new which I appreciated. I liked that the owner stood up for the worker.
I like their bagels which have always been fresh when I buy them. Their hazelnut coffee is excellent. Yes, its hectic at times. It's a bagel store in New York City its part of the vibe.
Several people mentioned they are expensive which is not my experience. I think the prices are reasonable for what you get. We are in an inflationary period and several other places in the area are much more money.
I love this bagel deli. I always enjoy the bagels, the fresh juices and the deli sandwiches. It’s really cute and has a lovely atmosphere.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Brooklyn
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes