Small little place. Loved the numerous available options - wings, pizza, subs, salads, pasta.
We got mild wings and those were pretty tasty. My kids loved it. I just wished it had a tab but more Buffalo sauce as it was a little dry.
Pizza - we ordered one large pizza to share. It wasn’t terrible but it wasn’t the best either. The inner crust was thinner than I expected but it was okay. My only con is that the crust had no flavor. Bland. No sure if that’s how they intended or that’s the style with thin pizzas but I usually like eating the crust. Even by itself. But this crust didn’t taste like anything but still had all the carbs. Couldn’t enjoy it as mush as like would’ve liked.
Garlic knots were good though! We’ll still come back!
If you like thin crust pizza this place is it, Also had the KY Bourbon wings which were great. Had the A/C running hard not their fault but dripped on our pizza had to slide to the side. Definitely would eat this again when back here.
This was by far the best pizza I have had. Was a little skeptical about it being called New York style, but it sure was on point. Definitely worth the trip if you are in the area!
Over the course of 3 days my husband and I ate here twice! First night was pizza, wings (extra extra extra extra crispy) & garlic knots- it was all so delicious! I had to call back to tell the man he did such a great job! I’m from upstate NY so I know good pizza and wings. The second time we went we got the Philly and wings, that Philly cheese stake was the best I’ve ever had! The calzone was good but could do without ricotta cheese. Everything was good and the people are there were nice. If we’re back in the area we would definitely be back to Mr. Maines pizzeria! We will be telling people about here! 🤤
I really enjoyed Mr. Maine's! Friendly staff that you can tell they like where they work.
Great dough, cooked perfectly with just the right amount of crunch and chew. Fresh ingredients....by the pie or the slice. Check for specials.
The wings are also really good. I like the parmesan garlic. Good sized wings, not small like some places.
Cold beer is also available.
I know everyone loves a certain pizza shop here, but this was a damn good pizza. The sauce was hearty and very flavorful. The crust was the perfect thickness, and the exact amount of seasonings on it. We got the supreme with pep, sausage, olives, onions, and peppers. The entire pizza was cooked through and not Gooey in the middle. Perfect cook. And the Greek salad was the perfect size for 2. And the garlic knots were on point as well. You could really enjoy the flavor of the garlic. I have eaten at MANY pizza shops over the US, and this would definitely make the top 15. This will most definitely be our pizza stop Everytime. Thanks for being an amazing little pizza shop. Great work.
Toppings were great, sauce was great. The small is really big enough for 2 people. Crust is a bit weird- not thin but not NY style either. Needs some slight improvements but decent pizza.
My family came here tonight and had the cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, kids spaghetti and meatball, calzone, and garlic knots. All the food was great. Staff was super friendly and helpful. Is it a 5 star fancy dining place? No. It's a down to earth pizza place with good food and great staff. Enjoy it for what it is.
If you want a place for under $40 a large new york style pizza, 10 wings, garlic knots with soda's, then this is the place. And they have large new York style slices so we had 2 slices left over to take home and free soda refills so you can fill up before you leave. I highly recommend this place.
So good I had to come back before we left!
No frills, no fuss, just good food. Pizza is excellent and hotwings are some of the best we've had. We ordered a large meats pizza and 10pc wings. We (2 adults) had enough pizza for 3 meals!
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Panama City Beach
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto