Friendly staff, great pizzas and the garlic knots are the best I’ve ever had so tasty and fluffy. Love in every bite..
Hands down the best pizza 🍕 I ever had on the island.The staff are wonderful oh and the Hero’s is just a whole another thing when I say it’s give taste they got it cover always fresh definitely won’t be disappointed the prices are good and food even better so stop looking and let slice 48 Satisfy your appetite your stomach would appreciate it if you
Always consistent, excellent pizza with spectacular service. Their specials are reasonably priced and change daily.
Best buffalo chicken slices in New York.
I've enjoyed paganos for the past 20 years. You can't do better than this local gem.
Great pizza! And The Manicotti is awesome! Chicken parm hero was delicious too! I order from them all the time. They always deliver in a timely manor and it's still nice and hot!
This is delicious pizza and the wings are good too. I am excited to try more of the menu. Definitely try this place.
Great Pizza...borderline the best I have ever had. ONLY reason I did not give a 5 star rating on this order was because I ordered a BBQ Chicken pizza that says it has "Chicken and BBQ Sauce;" however, it also had onion on it, and that is literally the one thing I despise the most in life. I noticed the SLICELIFE website I ordered from does not say onions, however, the other ordering sites appear to be correct. The main website, and DOORDASH appear to be correct. I hope they update the online ordering to reflect there is onion on this pizza so I can order it without next time. Kinda ruined the experience for this pizza...will not stop me from ordering again - albeit, I will be a bit more careful.
Pizza is the best on the North Fork! We visit here each summer and always get pizza from Pagano's. We always leave stuffed and very happy! The staff is also very friendly.
Got a large pie to go and it was terrific - one of the best pizzas on the North Fork and I have been to most of them on the NOFO
Delish pizza made fresh every day. Super friendly workers. Home made ingredients and the best part is they deliver!!!!
Descent lunches...Hero specials usually taste the best ad made to order. Friendly staff.
Prenota un tavolo
Ordina online
Trova il miglior ristorante di Southold
Si è verificato un errore! Riprova tra qualche minuto